in Search

Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

Last post 08-24-2009 3:55 PM by j2inet. 5 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (6 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-01-2009 1:15 PM

    Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

    I caught a new iPhone ad on TV last night that was entirely focused on two "new" features of the iPhone 3GS.  Cut and paste (with painstaking visuals showing exactly how to cut and paste!) and voice dialing/voice command that calls people and even plays media by voice control!

     

    Hmmm.... where have we seen all this before... 

     

    I'm waiting for a new Ford or GM ad touting that their new cars no longer need to be cranked to start due to their revolutionary new electric starters!  Wink

     

     

    --
    Todd Allcock [MS MVP - Mobile Devices]

    Current Devices:
    Sony Ericsson X1i (T-Mobile USA)
    T-Mobile MDA (T-Mobile 2 Go Prepaid)
    T-Mobile Dash (T-Mobile 2 Go Prepaid)
    Samsung SCH-i730 (Page Plus Cellular)
    Samsung SCH-i600 (Page Plus Cellular)
    Dell Axim X5
    Audiovox Maestro
    NEC MP780 HPC
    Zune 30



    • Post Points: 15
  • 07-01-2009 1:32 PM In reply to

    • Laura Rooke
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 03-27-2008
    • Northern California
    • Posts 4,274
    • Points 42,228
    • 4_ambassador
      Microsoft Windows Mobile MVP
      Moderator
      Small Business Specialist
      Specialist

    Re: Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

    And my son is totally taken by all this - and I think he is a typical iPhone user.

     

    Todd Allcock:
    I'm waiting for a new Ford or GM ad touting that their new cars no longer need to be cranked to start due to their revolutionary new electric starters! 

    That's so funny - a great analogy !

    Laura Rooke
    MVP - Mobile Devices
    My Devices..........
    IPAQ 3650
    IPAQ 5450
    IPAQ 4700
    IPAQ 2795
    Jasjar
    Motorola Q
    T-Mobile Dash
    AT&T TILT
    Advantage 7510
    HTC Pure
    HTC Diamond2
    Motorola Backflip
    • Post Points: 10
  • 07-01-2009 2:27 PM In reply to

    Re: Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

     I generally find the iPhone ads really annoying. I've oftened likened them in the past to something Fisher Price would produce. Spoon feeding you the information like you're a 2 year old. "It's as quick and easy as this" then a small print caveat at the bottom saying "sequence shortened and speeded up". How can they get away with that?

    Dave Parker
    Microsoft M.V.P. Mobile Devices
    Reviewer & Moderator - www.smartphonegurus.com
    My Blog - Guru Meditation
    • Post Points: 10
  • 07-02-2009 1:27 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

    Dave Parker MVP:

     I generally find the iPhone ads really annoying. I've oftened likened them in the past to something Fisher Price would produce. Spoon feeding you the information like you're a 2 year old. "It's as quick and easy as this" then a small print caveat at the bottom saying "sequence shortened and speeded up". How can they get away with that?

     

     

    Without sounding condescending to the general public, dumbing down and talking down actually works wonders. Smart phones seem so bloody complicated to most people. Its a problem Windows Mobile Phones suffer from. From the outside, they seem so hard to use and unfriendly. They are really capable of so much, and for many people, the gap between a dumb phone and a Windows Mobile phone is pretty huge. What Apple has done, is to try to dumb it down as easy as possible. People actually look at those commercials and think "Hey that doesn't look hard at all! Even I could do that!".

    More or less what Apple has done is bridge the gap between dumb phone buyers and smart phone buyers. Lets face it, the majority of cell phone users, are still using simple basic phones. Apple created a smart phone, for the mass general public. The iPhone is "the smart phone that anyone can use", or at least thats what Apples marketing would want you to believe. The money and sales aren't going to be found in the hardcore smart phone base. The type of people who read tech news sites, or post on tech forums is just a niche compared to the average joe. What Windows Mobile needs to do, (and what I believe 6.5 is a great step to) is to really branch off towards the mass market. Keep the power and performance of Windows Mobile, but streamline and simplify it a bit. Make smart phones seem... a little less scary. Of course, proper marketing helps. People need to see how easy and useful Windows Mobile can be.

    Look! My phone syncs up with email and office! Not only that, but my music from Windows Media Player syncs too. With live search, I can easily find places to go. And with Microsoft My Phone, theres no worries if its ever lost or stolen. Like phones with keyboards? We got those! How about with a big touch screen? We got those too! Whatever style phone you like, you can find it, with Windows Mobile. 


    • Post Points: 10
  • 07-02-2009 3:08 AM In reply to

    Re: Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

    Trademarked:

    Without sounding condescending to the general public, dumbing down and talking down actually works wonders. Smart phones seem so bloody complicated to most people. Its a problem Windows Mobile Phones suffer from. From the outside, they seem so hard to use and unfriendly. They are really capable of so much, and for many people, the gap between a dumb phone and a Windows Mobile phone is pretty huge. What Apple has done, is to try to dumb it down as easy as possible. People actually look at those commercials and think "Hey that doesn't look hard at all! Even I could do that!".

    More or less what Apple has done is bridge the gap between dumb phone buyers and smart phone buyers. Lets face it, the majority of cell phone users, are still using simple basic phones. Apple created a smart phone, for the mass general public. The iPhone is "the smart phone that anyone can use", or at least thats what Apples marketing would want you to believe. The money and sales aren't going to be found in the hardcore smart phone base. The type of people who read tech news sites, or post on tech forums is just a niche compared to the average joe. What Windows Mobile needs to do, (and what I believe 6.5 is a great step to) is to really branch off towards the mass market. Keep the power and performance of Windows Mobile, but streamline and simplify it a bit. Make smart phones seem... a little less scary. Of course, proper marketing helps. People need to see how easy and useful Windows Mobile can be.

    Look! My phone syncs up with email and office! Not only that, but my music from Windows Media Player syncs too. With live search, I can easily find places to go. And with Microsoft My Phone, theres no worries if its ever lost or stolen. Like phones with keyboards? We got those! How about with a big touch screen? We got those too! Whatever style phone you like, you can find it, with Windows Mobile. 


     

    Very well put.  Unfortunately the confused consumer is often even more confused by lousy salespeople- picking the right sales professional makes a world of difference, particularly when making a choice that will contractually obligate you for a couple of years.  I was at a Sam's Club Warehouse store earlier this evening, and was browsing the cell phone kiosk as I pathetically always do when shopping for some reason. (I owned a cell phone store for about six years and still miss it!)  A nice young lady wanted to upgrade her two family plan Sprint dumbphones to smartphones.  She assumed all QWERTYs were smartphones, and the well-meaning, but obviously untrained salesman was trying to set her straight.  From the best of my recollection, here was the exchange:

    Lady, holding Sanyo 2700 (IIRC) QWERTY: Is this a Blackberry?

    Salesman: No.  That phone has a keyboard a lot like a Blackberry, but it's not a smartphone.

    Lady: This can't get the internet?

    Salesman: Oh, it'll do internet, but it's not a smartphone.

    Lady: So what's the difference? 

    Salesman: Smartphones can do more.

    Lady: Like what?

    Salesman: More than that phone does...

    Every fiber of my being wanted me to scream, step in, and give a real demo, but after having spent nearly two decades in retail management and ownership, I've adopted a strict Prime Directive of non-interference, much like the crew of the Starship Enterprise, if only to protect my sanity, and prevent being confronted by store security.  So, instead, I just winced, grabbed the 36-roll bundle of paper towels and 2-Gallon bottle of dishwasher detergent I came in for a little bit tighter and headed to the checkout lines as he showed her a Samsung Instinct which he was describing as "almost exactly like a smartphone..."

     

     

    --
    Todd Allcock [MS MVP - Mobile Devices]

    Current Devices:
    Sony Ericsson X1i (T-Mobile USA)
    T-Mobile MDA (T-Mobile 2 Go Prepaid)
    T-Mobile Dash (T-Mobile 2 Go Prepaid)
    Samsung SCH-i730 (Page Plus Cellular)
    Samsung SCH-i600 (Page Plus Cellular)
    Dell Axim X5
    Audiovox Maestro
    NEC MP780 HPC
    Zune 30



    • Post Points: 5
  • 08-24-2009 3:55 PM In reply to

    • j2inet
    • Top 25 Contributor
    • Joined on 08-24-2009
    • Atlanta, GA
    • Posts 45
    • Points 315
    • 1_colleague

    Re: Anyone Annoyed and Amused by New iPhone ad?

    Those ads aren't just showing off features, they are training the customer on how to use features of the phone. There's a functional reason behind them.

    Joel Ivory Johnson
    @j2inet | Device Application Development MVP
    • Post Points: 5
Page 1 of 1 (6 items)
  * SHARE YOUR FEEDBACK ABOUT THE SITE USING OUR NEW FEEDBACK FORM *